Identifying and Managing Toxic Employees in the Workplace

Workplace toxicity can undermine productivity, morale, and overall organizational success. Toxic employees disrupt team dynamics, create unnecessary stress, and can even drive valuable employees to resign. Understanding the different types of toxic personalities in the workplace and how to manage them is essential for maintaining a healthy and efficient work environment. Toxic coworkers can take many forms, including passive-aggressive individuals, narcissists, underminers, bullies, chronic complainers, gossipers, micromanagers, and credit hogs, each of whom negatively impacts workplace dynamics in unique ways.

While toxic behavior varies from individual to individual, certain traits and patterns are commonly observed. This article explores different types of toxic employees and provides strategies for dealing with them effectively.

Must Read: 8 Tips on Toxic Work Environment Lawsuit

The Passive-Aggressive Employee

One of the most insidious forms of toxicity comes from employees who exhibit passive-aggressive tendencies. These individuals struggle to communicate openly, leading them to express their frustrations through indirect means rather than direct confrontation. They often lack the confidence or willingness to engage in open discussions, instead resorting to manipulation, sarcasm, and backhanded remarks to express their dissatisfaction.

Recognizing Passive-Aggressive Behavior

Some common passive-aggressive behaviors include:

Making backhanded compliments that subtly insult or diminish others

Providing the silent treatment to avoid confrontation while expressing displeasure

Using snide or sarcastic comments to undermine colleagues

Saying one thing but meaning another, leading to confusion and misinterpretation

Deliberately talking over others in meetings to assert control

Ignoring or pretending not to hear when addressed directly

Passive-aggressive employees tend to shift blame onto others, never taking responsibility for their actions. They may also retaliate subtly when they feel slighted, finding ways to make others feel uncomfortable or uncertain in their workplace interactions.

How to Manage a Passive-Aggressive Colleague

Dealing with passive-aggressive coworkers requires a combination of assertiveness and strategic communication. Here are some effective approaches:

Call out the behavior calmly – A direct but professional confrontation can dissuade passive-aggressive tendencies. Ask them for clarity on their statements to put them in a position where they must explain their true intentions.

Encourage open communication – Since they often avoid direct conflict, creating a space where they feel comfortable discussing concerns openly can be beneficial.

Maintain composure – Avoid engaging in their manipulative tactics. Instead, respond with professionalism and refuse to be drawn into their negative energy.

Set boundaries – If their behavior becomes disruptive, establish clear professional boundaries to prevent them from affecting your workflow.

The Narcissistic Employee

Narcissists in the workplace pose a significant challenge due to their inflated self-importance and lack of empathy. These individuals crave recognition, believe they are superior to others, and often take credit for work they did not contribute to.

Common Traits of a Workplace Narcissist

Dismisses the opinions, ideas, or feedback of others

Believes workplace rules, policies, and structures do not apply to them

Avoids accountability and shifts blame onto coworkers

Engages in manipulative tactics to advance their personal interests

Pits colleagues against each other to maintain control and dominance

Despite their confidence, narcissists can be a significant hindrance to team success. Their unwillingness to collaborate and acknowledge others' contributions creates a toxic work environment.

How to Handle a Narcissistic Colleague

Avoid engaging in their games – Narcissists thrive on conflict and manipulation. The less you react emotionally, the less power they have over you.

Document your work – Since they are likely to take credit for others’ efforts, keep detailed records of your contributions. Ensure your manager is aware of your role in projects.

Set firm boundaries – Establishing clear limits prevents them from taking advantage of your time and efforts.

Do not expect accountability – It is unlikely that they will admit wrongdoing, so instead, focus on protecting yourself and your work from their influence.

The Undermining Colleague

While some workplace competition can be healthy, professional underminers take it to a destructive level. These individuals sabotage their colleagues to elevate themselves, making it difficult for others to succeed.

Behaviors of an Underminer

Secretly sabotages colleagues’ success to make themselves look better

Takes credit for others' work or ideas

Constantly compares themselves to coworkers to assert superiority

Criticizes colleagues’ performance, often without justification

Seeks attention and redirects the spotlight onto themselves

Excludes coworkers from important meetings or discussions to hinder their contributions

Spreads rumors or misinformation to damage others’ reputations

Strategies for Dealing with an Underminer

Be vigilant – Keep an eye on their actions and avoid sharing too much information that they could use against you.

Speak up when necessary – If an underminer takes credit for your work, politely but firmly correct the record in a professional setting.

Create a strong support network – Having allies in the workplace can help counteract the underminer’s tactics.

Document interactions – Keeping a record of emails and project contributions ensures that your work is properly recognized.

The Workplace Bully

Workplace bullies seek to dominate, intimidate, and demean others. Their behavior often stems from their own insecurities, and they thrive on making others feel small. Unlike passive-aggressive employees, bullies are more overt in their actions, making them easier to recognize.

Signs of Workplace Bullying

Belittling, insulting, or humiliating coworkers

Using intimidation to control others

Excluding certain employees from meetings or social gatherings

Spreading malicious rumors or misinformation

Shouting, yelling, or using aggressive body language

Setting unrealistic deadlines or workloads to set others up for failure

Managing a Workplace Bully

Address the issue directly – If you feel safe doing so, calmly assert that their behavior is unacceptable.

Report incidents to management or HR – Documentation is key when dealing with a bully. Keep track of their behavior and report patterns to HR if necessary.

Do not engage emotionally – Bullies thrive on emotional reactions. Remaining calm and composed can reduce their power over you.

Seek support – Having trusted colleagues who can back up your experiences can provide additional credibility when raising concerns.

The Chronic Complainer

Some employees are never satisfied, no matter the circumstances. Chronic complainers bring down workplace morale and contribute to a toxic atmosphere by focusing solely on negatives.

Common Traits of a Complainer

Frequently grumbles about work-related matters without offering solutions

Drains motivation and enthusiasm from those around them

Resists constructive feedback or alternative perspectives

Finds fault in management, policies, colleagues, and job responsibilities

While occasional venting is normal, chronic complainers turn negativity into a habit, affecting team morale.

Handling a Complainer

Encourage problem-solving – Ask them what solutions they propose to their concerns rather than allowing them to dwell on negativity.

Set boundaries – Limit the time you spend listening to their complaints to avoid being affected by their negativity.

Maintain perspective – Recognize that their dissatisfaction is their issue, not yours. Avoid letting their complaints influence your outlook.

The Office Gossip

Gossipers thrive on spreading rumors and misinformation. Their actions can create distrust and division among colleagues, harming workplace relationships.

How to Deal with Gossipers

Do not participate – Refuse to engage in gossip or spread rumors.

Be direct – If a gossiper tries to involve you, let them know you prefer to focus on work rather than workplace drama.

Correct misinformation – If you hear false claims about yourself or others, clarify the truth in a professional manner.

The Micromanager

Micromanagers hover over their colleagues, offering excessive supervision and control. They struggle to trust others to complete tasks independently, leading to frustration and inefficiency.

Coping with a Micromanager

Demonstrate competence – Show that you are capable of handling responsibilities without excessive oversight.

Request autonomy – Politely express the importance of having space to work effectively.

Document expectations – Having clear expectations in writing can prevent misunderstandings and constant micromanagement.

Final Thoughts

Toxic colleagues can disrupt an otherwise healthy workplace, affecting productivity, morale, and mental well-being. While different toxic behaviors require different strategies, maintaining professionalism, setting boundaries, and documenting interactions are key approaches to managing them. If toxicity persists despite efforts to address it, escalating the issue to management or HR may benecessary. Protecting your own well-being and career should always be the top priority.